"I've wondered all night about you." - Belle and Sebastian, Roy Walker
Fables: The Great Fables Crossover by Bill Willingham and Matthew Sturges (2010, Vertigo). I haven't loved Fables nearly as much since War and Pieces ended and, essentially, everything changed. I'm usually not one to complain about change but, in this case, I am. While I still get bits of what I have enjoyed from Fables (reinvention of familiar characters in compelling ways, fairy tale stories retold through contemporary lenses, maturity, wit, and humor), it's not nearly as consistent and engrossing. This collection continues that trend.
The first challenge is that it's much more of a Jack of Fables story than a main book one. I've rarely cared for the Jack character and I've not been able to get into his stand-alone series at all. So, strike one. Then, it seems to require pretty intimate knowledge of that series to appreciate the story. The best comic book cross-overs tell you a great story that doesn't require much back knowledge but presents the characters in such a way that it makes you want to read their stories because you've enjoyed them so much in the one you've read. This, for me, doesn't do that at all. I don't know why the blue ox is there or how Mr. Revise and Kevin Thorn and the Pathetic Fallacy are related or why they are are on the run or anything. And you essentially need to know all of that to care about what's happening here. Strike two. And, lastly, it's a story about writing. It's over 200 pages of Willingham and Sturges complaining about writer's block. This villain, which actually could be meaningful in a fictional world built around characters that know they are fictional, isn't bad in and of itself but it is never presented as a real threat. Unlike The Adversary, who seemed a worthy and insurmountable foe, Kevin Thorn is just an annoying guy with great power that he never uses to any great effect. Strike three, you're out.
I'm still a Fables fan and will continue to pick up the collections until I'm just totally bored but this doesn't bode well.
Not recommended.
What I will recommend, though, is Cinderella: From Fabletown With Love. Chris Roberson and Shawn McManus are taking a deeper look at one of the most compelling and under-utilized characters in Fables, Cindy the spy, and put together a fun read. I'm picking it up by the issue, too, and not waiting for the collection.-
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=4f75b6aa-45af-4483-9dd9-7eb45483a6f9)